GENERAL

Exclusive | Grinning ex-NYPD cop admits to The Post that he killed NYC jogger — and says ‘Allah told me to’

By Khristina Narizhnaya5 min readNew York Post
Exclusive | Grinning ex-NYPD cop admits to The Post that he killed NYC jogger — and says ‘Allah told me to’

Allah told him to kill.

The maniac teacher’s aide and ex-cop arrested in the brutal killing of a Brooklyn jogger told The Post in an exclusive jailhouse interview that he was acting on orders delivered by his God.

“Allah told me to kill a person, so I killed her, the jogger Katie Suarez,” Sayed Mohassib, 27, said at the Eric M. Taylor Center at Riker’s Island jail on Saturday.

Former police officer Sayed Mohassib escorted by officers at Central Booking in Brooklyn, New York.
Former police officer Sayed Mohassib arrives at Central Booking in Brooklyn, New York, on Sunday, Nov. 8, 2026, following the Oct. 30 slaying of Katie Suarez. Kevin C. Downs for NY Post

Advertisement

“Two days before it happened, Allah told me I had to kill a person.”

Wearing a prison-issued khaki jumpsuit and with a crazed look in his eyes, Mohassib appeared to show no remorse for the Oct. 30 attack on Suarez as she ran along a path on the Shore Parkway Greenway, for which he took full responsibility – and said he thought “nothing” of it.

“Allah told me to do it, so I did it,” he said matter of factly, noting he never questioned the “order” at all. “At first I said that I didn’t do it, but now I’m saying that I did it because Allah told me to.”

Advertisement

He told The Post no less than five times that Allah was the reason he stabbed Suarez, 28, twice in the neck on both her right and left side — and coldly appeared to think the beloved bank teller was in the wrong place at the wrong time.

“I didn’t know her, she was just there,” Mohassib said, his jumpsuit unbuttoned at the chest to show his tiger, shark and Allah tattoos and his hair disheveled.

Though Mohassib told police that he blacked out and woke up covered in blood and with the murder weapon after being arrested in the killing Nov. 7, he told The Post he remembered far more than simply waking up covered in blood.

Sayed Mohassib's chest tattoos, including a shark, a tiger, and text featuring names like Allah and Donald Trump.
The killer had multiple tattoos mentioning Allah and Trump on his stomach. Obtained by the NY Post

Advertisement

“I got home from work, I got the knife, and I killed her … I went home, I cleaned up,” he said.

This is a developing story. Please check back for updates.

When asked if he had a message for the Suarez family, he only said “No. Allah told me to do it,” unapologetically.”

“There was a little blood …” he added, before abruptly ending the interview, moving quickly and decisively, taking big steps as he strode away.

Advertisement

Katie Suarez outdoors outdoors with plants and a table.
Sayed Mohassib stabbed Katie Suarez on October 30. Katie Suarez / Linkedin

Mohassib is being held at Rikers while he awaits arraignment after being charged with second-degree murder in Suarez’s killing.

He told police during his grilling at the 62nd Precinct stationhouse two weeks ago he ditched the knife in the garbage, and cops believe the trash was taken to a landfill, ending up at a New Jersey dump.

The ex-NYPD, ex-marine, returned to his job as a paraprofessional at PS 200 elementary school in Bath Beach after the killing, where colleagues noticed him talking to himself, speaking incoherently and acting erratically.

Advertisement

Sayed Mohassib in police uniform with American and city flags in the background.
Sayed Mohassib, 27, appears in a photo. Mohassib was charged with second-degree murder in the Oct. 30 slaying of Katie Suarez in Brooklyn. Sayed Mohassib/Facebook

He has a history of mental instability — with his own family calling 911 after he threatened to “chop them up,” according to sources.

He was spotted in the days after the killing leaving his Brooklyn home wearing only his underwear.

He worked for the NYPD force for only six weeks in 2022 before leaving to enlist in the Marines.

Advertisement


Here’s the latest on Katie Suarez, the NYC jogger who was stabbed during a run:

  • Slain jogger Katie Suarez remembered as ‘unforgettable’ at Brooklyn funeral
  • Lax checks and union apathy kept the accused jogger killer in NYC kids’ classrooms
  • Devastated dad of slain NYC jogger Katie Suarez rips schools’ failure to probe suspect’s bizarre behavior
  • Funeral set for slain NYC jogger Katie Suarez — as parents testify before grand jury

The Marines discharged him after deeming him psychologically unfit, and his attempts to rejoin the NYPD just three months after he had left were denied.

Mohassib had shown up at an NYPD post to request reinstatement, appearing disheveled and erratic — and he was transported to Bellevue Hospital that same day, sources told The Post.

He was denied any attempts at returning to the force. That’s when he returned to the Department of Education, where he had done a prior stint as a paraprofessional before joining the NYPD.

Advertisement

Neighbors previously told The Post Mohassib changed around three years ago, with one saying something happened after his NYPD stint, when he went for vacation to his native Egypt.

“He came back different. I don’t know what happened,” he told The Post.

Advertisement

The mosque he regularly attended, the Muslim American Society Youth Center, hosted a radical imam who preached about warfare against Jews and opposing the US government.

He was arrested at his Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, home Nov. 7 wearing a bright red Von Dutch jacket, showing no emotion as someone shouted, “F–k you!” from across the street.

He’s due in court Dec. 4 for his arraignment.