FOREX

Oh Dear, Condo Prices Dropped by 15% to 34% in 40 Bigger Markets Already, and by 8% to 14% in another 28 Markets

By Wolf Richter9 min readWolfStreet.com
Oh Dear, Condo Prices Dropped by 15% to 34% in 40 Bigger Markets Already, and by 8% to 14% in another 28 Markets

In 6 markets, prices have plunged back to where they’d been 20 years ago.

Prices of mid-tier condos through October have dropped by 15% to 34% from their respective peaks in 40 bigger markets, depicted in the charts below.

Six more cities on the list: In six more cities, prices fell enough to move them onto this list, from the fell-14%-or-less list, in the two months since I last posted this update. In October, those six cities were down by 15% or more from their respective peaks, including Sacramento, CA; Dallas, TX; San Antonio, TX; and Huntsville, AL.

The majority of the peaks occurred in mid-2022, the rest in 2023 and 2024, ending the price explosions that had occurred from mid-2020 to mid-2022, on top of the steep price increases in prior years.

Prices of mid-tier condos dropped by 20% or more in 12 of these 40 markets, including 3 markets with 30%-plus drops (Cape Coral, FL; Oakland, CA; St. Petersburg, FL). In Austin, TX, prices dropped by 29% line. These are significant price drops.

Dropped below 2006 levels: In 6 of these 34 markets, condo prices have plunged below their highs during Housing Bubble 1 in 2006. Prices in those markets are now back where they’d been 20 years ago.

  1. Cape Coral, FL;
  2. Oakland, CA;
  3. Fort Myers, FL;
  4. Sarasota County, FL;
  5. Orlando, FL;
  6. Contra Costa County (San Francisco Bay Area), CA.

Condos can be a great home for hassle-free, worry-free, convenient living in an urban center with lots of amenities (such as pool, gym, staffed front desk that takes packages and announces visitors, etc.). Condos in towers tend to come with spectacular views. Condos in high-end towers in expensive cities can carry price tags of many millions of dollars.

Condos come in all sizes, from studios to palaces spread across entire floors or multiple floors of condo towers. Citadel founder Ken Griffin paid $238 million in 2019 for the multi-floor penthouse condo at 220 Central Park South, a tower on Billionaire’s Row in Manhattan, the most expensive home purchase in the US at the time. When it comes to condos, there’s something for everyone.

But… condos are subject to dynamics that can lead to massive bubbles and busts, and now there are additional issues, including a Fannie Mae condo blacklist that can hammer prices (see discussion below the charts: “A reminder of the special issues condos face”).

Condo prices exploded in two years from mid-2020 to mid-2022 by 50%, 60%, or even 70% in some of the markets, on top of the already steep price increases in prior years. In the 10 years to their respective peaks, prices had soared by 180% to 350% in these markets. And many of those bubbles are now painfully deflating.

Most of the markets here are “cities.” But several are counties whose numerous cities – though often household names – are too small to be included individually. The list includes one metropolitan statistical area for the same reasons. New York County is also included, which is Manhattan where condos are a big part of the market.

These 40 condo markets are depicted in 39 charts below (no chart for Huntsville, AL, because the ZHVI condo data for it doesn’t go back further than 2008).

Mid-tier condo prices fell by 15% to 34% from peak
Condo MarketSince peakYear of peak
1Cape Coral, FL-34%2022
2Oakland, CA-32%2022
3St. Petersburg, FL-30%2022
4Austin, TX-29%2022
5Fort Myers, FL-28%2023
6Sarasota County, FL-24%2022
7Garland, TX-23%2022
8Tampa, FL-22%2022
9Jacksonville, FL-22%2022
10Arlington, TX-21%2024
11Denver, CO-20%2022
12Aurora, CO-20%2022
13Orlando, FL-19%2024
14Lakeland-Winter Haven, metro, FL-19%2023
15Detroit, MI-19%2021
16Seattle, WA-19%2022
17Collier County (Naples), FL-18%2022
18Raleigh, NC-18%2022
19Plano, TX-18%2022
20Hayward, CA-18%2022
21Fort Lauderdale, FL-18%2024
22Contra Costa County, CA, Bay Area’s 2nd largest county-17%2022
23Port Saint Lucie, FL-17%2024
24Mesa, AZ-17%2022
25Manhattan, NY (New York County)-17%2022
26Fremont, CA-17%2022
27Portland, OR-16%2022
28Chandler, AZ-16%2022
29Houston, TX-16%2024
30Glendale, AZ-16%2022
31Phoenix, AZ-15%2022
32Irving, TX-15%2023
33Tempe, AZ-15%2022
34San Mateo County (northern Silicon Valley), CA-15%2022
35Huntsville, AL-15%2022
36San Antonio, TX-15%2024
37Dallas, TX-15%2023
38Sacramento, CA-15%2022
39Boise, ID-15%2022
40Reno, NV-15%2022

Cities were prices dropped less than 15%.

There are many markets where condo prices have dropped from their peaks in prior years, but by less than 15% so far.

Here is a sample of 28 bigger cities where condo prices have dropped by 8% to 14% (they don’t have their own charts here).

Mid-tier condo prices fell by 8% to 14%
Condo MarketSince peakYear of peak
1Queens, NY-14%2022
2Colorado Springs, CO-14%2022
3Las Vegas, NV-14%2022
4Stockton, CA-14%2022
5Modesto, CA-14%2022
6Scottsdale, AZ-14%2022
7Henderson, NV-13%2022
8Corpus Christi, TX-13%2023
9Atlanta, GA-12%2023
10Spokane, WA-11%2022
11San Jose, CA-11%2022
12Nashville, TN-11%2022
13Washington, DC-10%2022
14Los Angeles, CA-10%2022
15Tucson, AZ-10%2023
16Memphis, TN-10%2024
17Wilmington, NC-10%2022
18San Diego, CA-10%2023
19Marietta GA-10%2024
20Minneapolis, MN-9%2021
21Salt Lake City, UT-9%2022
22Fort Worth, TX-9%2024
23Long Beach, CA-9%2023
24St. Louis, MO-9%2023
25Oklahoma City, OK-8%2023
26New Orleans-8%2022
27Lubbock, TX-8%2022
28Miami, FL-8%2023

San Francisco, the epicenter of AI mania, came off this list entirely earlier this year because condo prices have been exploding, along with single-family home prices and rents, driven by the tsunami of money that AI companies headquartered in the City, particularly Anthropic and OpenAI, have been throwing in all directions, including via stock-based compensation.

Year-over-year, prices of mid-tier condos spiked by 14% in San Francisco, but they’re still 4% below their peak in mid-2022.

San Francisco, CA, City, Condo Prices
From May 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-4%1.5%14.4%177%

Methodology and data: These prices here are seasonally adjusted three-month averages of “mid-tier” condos and co-ops from the Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI), which is backward-looking index, based on millions of data points in Zillow’s “Database of All Homes,” including from public records (tax data), MLS, brokerages, local Realtor Associations, real-estate agents, and households across the US. It includes pricing data for off-market deals and for-sale-by-owner deals.

How Condo Bubbles deflate in charts.

The tables for each market below show from left to right for mid-tier condo prices: decline from the peak, change from prior month (MoM), change year-over-year (YoY), and remaining increase since January 2000.

Cape Coral, City, FL, Condo Prices
From July 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-34%-0.3%-6.5%124%

Oakland, CA, City, Condo Home Prices
From May 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-32%-0.4%-5.5%139%

St. Petersburg, Fl, City, Condo Prices
From Oct 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-30%-0.2%-5.0%174%

Austin, TX, City, Condo Prices
From Jul 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-29%-0.3%-5.2%101%

Fort Myers, FL, City, Condo Prices
From July 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-28%-0.2%-6%117%

Sarasota County, FL, Condo & Co-ops Prices
From Jun 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-24%0.2%-2.6%131%

Garland, TX, City, Condo Prices
From July 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-23%-0.6%-11.6%196%

Tampa, FL, City, Condo Prices
From Sep 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-22%-0.4%-6.2%238%

Jacksonville, FL, City, Condo Prices
From Nov 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-22%-0.4%-6.0%134%

Arlington, TX, City, Condo Prices
From Jun 2024 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-21%-1.1%-6.2%238%

Denver, CO, City, Condo Prices
From Jul 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-20%-0.6%-5.6%123%

Aurora, CO, City, Condo Prices
From Jul 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-20%-0.5%-6.4%184%

Orlando, FL, City, Condo Prices
From Jan 2024 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-19%-0.6%-6.5%140.6%

Lakeland-Winter Haven, FL, MSA, Condo Prices
From July 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-19%-0.3%-6.5%116%

Detroit, MI, City, Condo Prices
From Sep 2021 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-19%-0.2%-4.4%252%

Seattle, WA, City, Condo Prices
From Jun 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-19%-0.9%-5.9%126%

Collier County (Naples), FL, Condo & Co-ops Prices
From Jun 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-18%0.1%-2.4%153%

Raleigh, NC, City, Condo Prices
From July 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-18%-0.5%-7.9%126.5%

Plano, TX, City, Condo Prices
From Aug 2023 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-18%-0.5%-7.7%118%

Hayward, CA, City, Condo Prices
From July 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-18%-0.4%-6.2%171%

Fort Lauderdale, FL City, Condo & Co-op Prices
From Jul 2024 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-18%-0.6%-6.5%#DIV/0!

Contra Costa County (East Bay), CA, Condo & Co-Op Prices
From Jun 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-17%-0.4%-3.9%130%

Port Saint Lucie, FL, City, Condo Prices
From July 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-17%-0.1%-4.8%218.5%

Mesa, AZ, City, Condo Prices
From Aug 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-17%-0.4%-5.2%189%

Fremont, CA, City, Condo Prices
From May 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-17%-0.4%-5.8%188.2%

Portland, OR, City, Condo Prices
From Jun 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-16%-0.5%-3.7%103%

Chandler, AZ, City, Condo Prices
From Aug 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-16%-0.4%-4.7%201.9%

Houston, TX, City, Condo Prices
From Aug 2023 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-16%-0.7%-6.1%61%

Glendale, AZ, City, Condo Prices
From July 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-16%-1%-6%228%

Phoenix, AZ, City, Condo Prices
From Aug 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-15%-0.4%-3.8%223%

Irving, TX, City, Condo Prices
From May 2024 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-15%-0.6%-6.0%130%

Tempe, AZ, City, Condo Prices
From Jul 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-15%-0.2%-5.4%154.8%

San Mateo County, CA, Condo & Co-op Prices
From Jun 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-15%0.1%-1.3%194%

San Antonio, TX, City, Condo Prices
From Aug 2023 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-15%-0.5%-4.1%120%

Dallas, TX, City, Condo Prices
From Oct 2023 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-15%-0.3%-6.4%141%

Sacramento, CA, City, Condo Prices
From Jun 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-15%-0.4%-5.2%262%

Boise, ID, City, Condo Prices
From Jun 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2001
-15%-0.2%-1%#DIV/0!

Reno, NV, City, Condo Prices
From Jun 2022 peakMoMYoY Since 2000
-15%0.2%-0.4%242%

A reminder of the special issues condos face:

  • Over the long term, land appreciates, but most buildings depreciate and are eventually torn down. The land that big condo buildings sit on can be very valuable, but each condo owner only owns a tiny slice of it. The rest of their investment is in the building. A single-family house may sit on less valuable land, but the homeowner owns all of it.
  • Prices that exploded over the past few years ended up being way too high, once the mania settled down.
  • Hefty special assessments, or the fear of them, for long-neglected major repairs dog some older condo buildings. This is a particular issue in Florida, but elsewhere too.
  • Big increases in HOA fees at many properties, partly driven by spiking insurance costs in natural disaster zones, add substantially to the monthly costs of condos.
  • If a condo building is on Fannie Mae’s Blacklist, financing a unit in that building can be difficult, and sales may be limited to cash buyers who know that and exact their pound of flesh.
  • The Free Money has ended, and mortgage rates are roughly back to a normal range. Buyers of single-family homes face the same issue.
  • Foreign-based owners who’ve become frustrated with the US and became sellers add supply, while demand from foreign buyers has waned.
  • Investors in condos as rental properties are facing stiff competition from a wave of newly completed higher-end apartment buildings that developers are trying to find tenants for.