ZAI vs. MiniMax: Which Chinese AI lab looks better placed amid growing headwinds?
ZAI and Minimax are both nursing deep losses in recent weeks, amid increasing pressure on Chinese artificial intelligence valuations from concerns of U.S. regulatory scrutiny and more restrictions on their access to advanced computing chips.
Said concerns came to a head this week after the U.S. effectively closed a loophole allowing Chinese companies to remotely access Nvidia’s advanced AI chips hosted in offshore data centers.
Both stocks are growing revenue at triple-digit rates and losing heavily, but they sit in different places. MiniMax Group Inc (0100) is the cheaper stock and has the weaker income statement. ZAI Co Ltd (2513) has the better gross margin and smaller losses, but a far richer price tag. Neither has fully wiped out its gains by the same measure. MiniMax is at its 52-week low, and ZAI is still about 3x above its own.
Price Action
| ZAI | MiniMax | Edge | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price (Nov 18, 11:59 AM HKT) | HK$344.8 | HK$114.3 | - |
| YTD | +187.3% | -51.4% | ZAI |
| 6M | -69.7% | -85.7% | ZAI |
| 1W | -30.9% | -36.5% | ZAI |
| vs 52W high | about -88% | about -91% | Similar |
| vs 52W low | about 3x above | at the low | ZAI |
The two stocks are moving together. The difference is the starting point. ZAI had far more gains to give back, so it still shows a YTD profit. MiniMax has already breached its IPO price.
Fundamentals Face-Off
| FY2025 | ZAI | MiniMax | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $103.6M | $79.0M | ZAI |
| Revenue growth | 131.9% | 158.9% | MiniMax |
| Gross margin | 41.0% (from 56.3%) | 25.4% (from 12.2%) | ZAI on level, MiniMax on trend |
| Net income | -$672M | -$1.87B | ZAI |
| Loss / revenue | about 6.5x | about 24x | ZAI |
- Margin direction: ZAI’s gross margin fell about 15 points while revenue scaled. MiniMax’s more than doubled. MiniMax is improving from a weak base, and ZAI is slipping from a strong one.
- Loss trajectory: MiniMax’s net loss grew about 4x in a year, from -$465M to -$1.87B. ZAI’s grew about 66%, from -$405M to -$672M. MiniMax is burning money much faster.
Valuation Showdown
| Valuation | ZAI | MiniMax |
|---|---|---|
| Market cap (Nov 18, 2026) | ~$19.9B | ~$5.2B |
| Implied price/sales | ~190x | ~65x |
| Fair Value Upside (Nov 17) | -5.0% | +53.6% |
| Analyst target upside (Nov 17) | +284.8% | +349.0% |
| RSI (14d, Nov 17) | 30.5 | 27.6 |
Price/sales was calculated from market cap and FY2025 revenue, so it ignores growth since then. On this measure MiniMax is about one-third as expensive as ZAI. The model fair value points the same way: it treats ZAI as roughly fairly priced and MiniMax as undervalued. Analyst targets are large for both and are the least reliable signal here, because such large gaps tend to reflect uncertainty rather than conviction.
Who Has the Better Case?
- MiniMax bull: Cheaper on every valuation measure. Faster growth, improving margins, and more cash than debt. Quality concerns around its M3.1 Flash model are the main near-term worry.
- MiniMax bear: The -$1.87B loss, sitting at its 52-week low, and little evidence that its pricing edge survives the price war.
- ZAI bull: Higher margin, smaller losses relative to revenue, and a large cushion above its lows.
- ZAI bear: About 190x sales leaves little room for error. Fair value shows no upside, and the privacy controversy over its coding assistant is a reputational risk the other stock doesn’t carry.
The trade-off comes down to price against quality. MiniMax offers the larger potential rebound with the shakier financials, and ZAI offers sturdier economics at a price that already assumes success. MiniMax Group Inc (0100) breaking below its 52-week low of HK$114.0 would show selling is still intensifying. Neither stock looks like a clear buy at these levels, and both suit only investors who can tolerate sharp swings.