STOCK MARKETS

Three ways to beat the S&P 500 in a bubbly market

By Norman Rothery4 min readThe Globe and Mail
Three ways to beat the S&P 500 in a bubbly marketThree ways to beat the S&P 500 in a bubbly market

The market is now fuelled by dreams of what artificial intelligence might provide

Americans are looking forward to celebrating Thanksgiving after a dreary year filled with war, inflation and politics.

Despite the stressful times, the U.S. stock market continued its bull run, which started way back in 2020. But the market is now fuelled by dreams of what artificial intelligence might provide.

It’s high time to check in on three U.S. portfolios that mirror the methods used by some of the Canadian portfolios we regularly follow at The Globe and Mail.

The U.S. versions of the Free Cash, Frugal Dividend and Stable Dividend portfolios outperformed with average annual gains of 19.1, 12.4 and 10.1 per cent, respectively, over the 27 years through to the end of October 2026. In comparison, the U.S. stock market, as represented by the S&P 500 index, climbed at an average annual rate of 8.5 per cent over the same period.

(Returns herein are based on backtests using monthly data from Bloomberg. They include dividend reinvestment but not fund fees, taxes, commissions or other trading costs. The portfolios are equally weighted and rebalanced monthly.)

The three portfolios pick stocks from within the S&P 500 index itself using different tests of low volatility (variability of daily percentage changes in total returns) and value.

The U.S. Stable Dividend portfolio buys the 20 stocks from within the index with the lowest volatilities over the prior 260 days. The idea isto buy relatively stable past performers with the expectation they’ll continue to offer fairly smooth rides – and reasonable returns – in the future.

The U.S. Frugal Dividend portfolio starts with the 50 stocks with the lowest volatilities over the prior 260 days in the index and then picks the 10 with the lowest positive price-to-earnings ratios. The portfolio seeks both relatively stability while hunting for good value stocks along the way.

The U.S. Free Cash portfolio seeks deep value stocks from within the index by picking the 10 with the lowest positive enterprise value to free-cash-flow ratios (EV/FCF). It sticks to some of the best values on offer, but its high returns were also the most volatile of the three portfolios.

(Enterprise value is equal to a company’s market capitalization plus its net debt. Free cash flow is theoretically the amount of money a company can distribute to its shareholders while maintaining its operations, and it’s approximated by subtracting capital expenditures from operating cash flow.)

You can examine the return histories of the U.S. portfolios and the market index in the accompanying graph.

While the portfolios posted grand long-term returns, they suffered from some big downturns along the way. For instance, during thefinancial crisis of 2008-2009, the market index fell 51 per cent from its former high while the U.S. Free Cash portfolio plunged 70 per cent. On the other hand, the portfolios that favoured stocks with low prior volatilities fared relatively well, with the U.S. Stable Dividend portfolio giving up 28 per cent and the U.S. Frugal Dividend portfolio down 42 per cent.

The crash that started in 2000 when the internet bubble burst offers a better guide to today’s market. The market index fell 45 per cent from its high in 2000 to its low in 2002. But the portfolios were stronger, with the U.S. Stable Dividend and U.S. Frugal Dividend portfolios falling just 11 and 16 per cent from their former highs, respectively. The more volatile U.S. Free Cash portfolio fell 30 per cent.

While the bubbly state of the U.S. market echoes the late 1990s, it’s not a perfect match because the enthusiastic mood is not limited to AI-related companies.

For instance, the stocks in the S&P 500 index have a median dividend yield of 1.86 per cent, a median earnings yield of 4.4 per cent and a median FCF/EV yield of 3.6 per cent. In comparison, 10-year U.S. Treasury bonds have recently offered yields near 5 per cent. As a result, investors are expecting a good deal of earnings growth from U.S. companies, which seems a little doubtful given the state of the world.

With perhaps large dollop of luck, the market might continue to climb higher and allow investors to enjoy many Thanksgiving holidays to come. On the other hand, it also has a habit of snatching away the punch bowl unexpectedly. It’ll be interesting to see how the U.S. portfolios fare through thick and thin.

Details on the stocks in the three U.S. portfolios, and the others regularly followed at The Globe and Mail, can be found via this link.

Norman Rothery, PhD, CFA, is the founder of StingyInvestor.com.