STOCK MARKETS

Shift to fee-based compensation will soften the impact from total cost reporting

By Joel Schlesinger5 min readThe Globe and Mail
Shift to fee-based compensation will soften the impact from total cost reportingShift to fee-based compensation will soften the impact from total cost reporting
CRM3 involves total cost reporting for management and trading costs on mutual funds, segregated funds and exchange-traded funds in dollar terms.

Experts say a minority of advisors are likely to feel the negative effects of CRM3

CRM3 involves total cost reporting for management and trading costs on mutual funds, segregated funds and exchange-traded funds in dollar terms.Hengki Lestio/iStockPhoto / Getty Images

This ongoing series explores how advisors, dealers and asset managers are preparing for the total cost reporting statements clients will receive in early 2027.Read the first article in the series here and the second article here.

Some advisors may be anxious about the new fee reports clients will be receiving in the new year.

Yet, the third phase of the client relationship model, or “CRM3,” is likely to be less impactful than CRM2, says Carlos Cardone, head of client engagement at Toronto-based Investor Economics, an ISS Market Intelligence business.

“There’s already a lot of disclosure, particularly on advisor fees,” that happened with CRM2, he says, including a breakdown of advisor and dealer costs in percentage and dollar terms.

The implementation of CRM2 in 2017 didn’t trigger a wave of investors changing advisors because they were unhappy with what they were paying for advice, he says. “What’s being added now just completes the picture, but it’s not nearly as revolutionary.”

CRM3 involves total cost reporting (TCR) for management and trading costs on mutual funds, segregated funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) in dollar terms. It also adds a new requirement for a fund expense ratio combining the management expense ratio and trading expense ratio.

Susan Vincent, a fee-based insurance advisor and family business consultant with Propel Insurance and Advisory Inc. at iA Private Wealth Inc. in Calgary, has been involved in iA’s CRM3 planning for its advisors. She says some advisors will be affected negatively by it.

“It will likely weed out advisors who don’t serve clients actively,” she says.

But the wealth management industry’s shift from a trailer commission model on fund sales to a fee-based model on assets under management (AUM) will soften the impact of CRM3.

About 70 per cent of full-service brokerage assets are now managed through fee-based accounts, Mr. Cardone says, up from about 50 per cent a decade ago.

Rory Galvin, founder and chief executive of Navirum Inc., an industry consulting firm helping advisors and dealers with CRM3 implementation, says the impact will likely be less than with CRM2.

But “advisors still need to be able to explain it all to their clients clearly” when clients start seeing the enhanced fee reporting next year, he says.

The CRM regulations have been more of a trend “accelerator” than a key driver, Mr. Cardone says. The growth of separately managed accounts (SMAs) among high-net-worth clients may have been partly accelerated by CRM3, as advisors sought to move them to lower-fee products, he says. In addition, reporting SMAs’ trading costs was already mandatory under CRM2 because they hold individual securities.

“In terms of winners and losers, what’s already been losing ground generally are higher-cost investment funds – typically actively managed mutual funds with management fees of at least 80 or 90 basis points,” he says.

Yet, the share of those funds by AUM has been falling during the past two decades as ETFs’ popularity has grown, Mr. Cardone says.

Year-to-date fund flows in Canada (as of Sept. 30) illustrate ETFs’ growing dominance. Of the $196-billion in net sales, $155-billion flowed to ETFs and $25-billion went to mutual funds holding ETFs as the underlying asset, according to data from Investor Economics.

The majority of the $41-billion in mutual fund flows likely went to Series F funds that exclude trailer fees, Mr. Cardone says.

Series A funds, which include trailing commissions, would have accounted for a sliver of flows, he adds. Still, these higher-fee funds represent a large share of total mutual fund AUM in Canada – about $955-billion of the roughly $2.5-trillion of mutual fund AUM at the end of 2025, according to Investor Economics.

Mr. Cardone says most of those funds are likely held by millions of mass-market investors through bank-channel advisors who may not use a fee-based model.

Often, these investors have less than $250,000 of investable assets. In aggregate, their AUM doesn’t represent a major revenue source for advisors compared with wealthier Canadians – about 6 per cent of households that account for more than three quarters of AUM in Canada, he adds.

“Those are Canadians with more than $1-million in investable assets,” and they’re often the investors requiring advisor assistance because their wealth is more “complicated,” he says.

Still, that large majority of Canadian investors is part of another trend: the growth of discount brokerages and do-it-yourself investing. Online brokerage growth has been much faster than growth for any advice-based channel, Mr. Cardone says.

Kuno Tucker, chief compliance officer at online brokerage Questrade Inc., says TCR will further “sharpen” investors’ understanding of the fees they pay.

“We expect that visibility to drive more people to look at their options closely, whether that’s managing their own portfolio or choosing a low-cost managed solution,” he says.

Ms. Vincent says the discount brokerage trend has been affecting advisors for years, adding that advisors like her are seeing fewer younger clients because this demographic is gravitating to DIY investing or low-fee robo-advisors.

“That’s an ongoing challenge that will only grow over the next decade, even for high-value advisors,” she says, pointing to pending federal regulations that will make it easier to move accounts from one provider to another and for discount brokerages to provide limited guidance.

Although CRM3 is unlikely to “create a mass exodus” to discount brokerages, she says, it will likely increase pressure on advisors to demonstrate value beyond product selection and to reduce the fees they charge.

“You must have an increasingly efficiently run business to compete,” Ms. Vincent says. “Now is the time to get your ducks in a row.”