STOCK MARKETS

Memory chips vs. optical: which theme has stronger upside support

By Investing.com3 min readInvesting.com
Memory chips vs. optical: which theme has stronger upside support

On the evidence gathered, memory looks like the better-supported upside story. Optical has the sharper, more volatile rebound potential. Neither is cheap after a large run. This is a read of the data, not a recommendation.

Why memory leads

An Investing.com piece from Aug 14, 2026 summarized why institutions favor memory: scale ($1T+ vs. $60–80B for optical), deeper analyst coverage, and HBM demand visibility. It cited these growth figures:

  • Micron (MU): 167% revenue growth.
  • SK Hynix (000660): 145% revenue growth.
  • Lumentum (LITE): 83.2% revenue growth.
  • Coherent: 18% revenue growth.

The same article quotes Micron’s estimate that the HBM market grows from $35B in 2025 to $100B by 2028, a 40% CAGR.

Optical’s case rests on policy protection against Chinese transceiver imports, record bookings and 200G-per-lane technology leadership. The catch is that much of this is already priced in. The article notes LITE and MU have both gained about 700% over the cycle.

Where prices stand

All figures are as of Oct 26, 2026, 3:27 PM EDT.

StockPrice1MYTDTake
Micron (MU)$910.88-15.8%+208.7%Scale leader, 27% below its 52W high ($1,255)
Lumentum (LITE)$829.19-12.0%+118.5%Up 9.7% today, 27% below its high ($1,143)
SK hynix ADR (SKHY)$143.02-25.4%-15.9%Laggard of the group, near its 52W low of $124.80

Insights

  • Catch-up candidate: SK hynix has fallen furthest, so it has the most room to recover if HBM demand holds. It also has the most room to keep falling if the market is pricing peak margins.
  • Balance sheet: The Aug 17 comparison flagged LITE’s 36% debt-to-equity as a risk the memory names don’t carry.
  • Bear case for both: Every name here fell 12–25% in the past month. That points to a sector-wide pullback, not a problem with one company.

ETF candidates

Screener snapshots may lag live prices.

ETFTheme1Y returnRSI
Roundhill Memory ETF (DRAM)Memory+69.5%33.5
Tema Photonics & Optical ETF (LAZR)Optical-33.5%29.4
KraneShares Photonic & Optical ETF (LUMA)Optical-18.2%32.0
VanEck Semiconductor ETF (SMH)Broad chips, 0.35% fee+50.6%35.3
  • Memory: DRAM is the clear leader, with about $18.4B in assets and a positive 1Y return. Other memory funds are small and negative: Tema Memory ETF (DISK) is -43%.
  • Optical: The pure-play funds are young and small. LAZR has about $179M in assets and LUMA about $8M. Both are down over 18%.
  • Broad option: SMH holds both themes plus other chip names, which cuts concentration risk.
  • Avoid for long-term holds: The 2x and 3x leveraged funds reset daily, so their returns drift from the index over time.
  • Oversold readings: Every fund listed has an RSI near or below 35. That means oversold, which can precede a bounce or a continued slide.

Implications

  • Memory: More fundamental support and scale, and the HBM growth trend is documented.
  • Optical: Higher beta and policy tailwinds, but thinner coverage and more leverage.
  • Mixed approach: SMH or a pairing of DRAM with an optical fund would cover both themes.

Price and sector data were checked but not valuation multiples or analyst targets, so a comparison of how expensive each theme is has not been made.