Deutsche Bank’s Italian unit hid up to €800 mln in losses - report
Deutsche Bank’s Italian division concealed as much as €800 million in losses through derivative transactions and shadow bookkeeping over more than a decade, the Financial Times reported on Thursday, citing leaked internal documents reviewed by the newspaper and partner media organisations.
Italian managers established a local reserve known as "tesoretto," or little treasure box, to conceal their failure to meet profit targets. The scheme continued until a whistleblower raised concerns in 2018.
An internal investigation, codenamed Project Aetos, uncovered failures in retail banking operations and mortgage-related risk management. Deutsche Bank never publicly disclosed the scandal or the findings.
"Aetos was a huge deal internally," one person with first-hand knowledge told the FT, adding that it "caused a real earthquake within the bank, and the regulators were absolutely furious."
Between 2018 and 2023, Deutsche Bank headquarters injected €1 billion in fresh capital into its Italian unit, according to the bank’s 2023 annual accounts.
The investigation found that the Italian division entered into €900 million in derivative positions with no economic rationale. Staff in Milan also used manipulated loan loss provisions to create the hidden reserve, drawing on it to meet profit targets in 2011, 2014 and 2016.
The misconduct centred on a 2007 change to Italian law allowing households to repay fixed-rate mortgages early without additional costs.
Deutsche Bank’s Italian unit failed for more than a decade to adjust its pricing and risk management models accordingly. Milan also stopped sharing lending data with headquarters, leaving €2.8 billion in lending and €1.4 billion in early repayments unrecorded.
The bank did not fire employees involved in the scheme. Some departing executives received seven-figure payouts, and Deutsche Bank chose not to claw back €5.25 million in deferred compensation.
Former Italian unit head Flavio Valeri, who led the division for 12 years, received a collective written warning alongside local CFO Carmine Di Martino and private banking head Mario Cincotto. All three were cleared of personal misconduct but reprimanded over managerial shortcomings.
KPMG, which audited the Italian arm during the misconduct period, failed to detect the scheme and later advised that no restatement of accounts was necessary.
Deutsche Bank told the FT it had thoroughly examined historical matters in its Italian unit and informed relevant stakeholders appropriately. It said no further group-level disclosure was necessary because the matter was not a material driver of group or segmental performance.
The affair raises questions about Chief Executive Christian Sewing, who oversaw an internal audit investigation in 2014 that identified risk management problems, though proposed changes were never implemented.
Deutsche Bank disclosed to the European Central Bank in 2020 a financial hit of €522 million, with potential total losses of €779 million including unrealised losses.