Citi sees Japanese stocks gaining into year-end
Citi said Japanese equities were likely to recover toward the end of 2026, arguing that a sharp sell-off on November 6 priced in a recession it did not expect.
The brokerage said current share prices could not be justified unless the global and Japanese economies entered clearly defined recessions, starting with a pullback in U.S. AI and data center investment.
Japanese stocks fell sharply in early-November, with the Nikkei 225down over 7% so far in the month. Investors grew concerned that the U.S. midterm elections would lead to tighter regulation of AI and data center spending.
Concerns over more interest rate hikes by the Bank of Japan also weighed, after the central bank officially declared victory against deflation, opening up the door to more monetary tightening.
This saw the Japanese stock decline extend well beyond the tech sector, which Citi said pointed to expectations of a broad deterioration in the economy and corporate earnings.
Citi estimated that the earnings per share (EPS) implied by the November 6 close was roughly 20% below current consensus. That was equivalent to a decline of nearly 30% in overall Japanese EPS for fiscal 2027, it said.
Downward revisions of more than 20%, or declines of more than 30%, had been seen only during recessions, Citi said.
The market also implied a fall of more than 50% year-on-year in fiscal 2027 EPS for the tech sector, as measured by MSCI Japan IT. Citi called that pricing excessive.
Tech accounted for only about 23% of TOPIX, and Citi said it was difficult to see overall EPS falling by more than 30% even if tech earnings halved, provided other sectors held firm. It said the market was effectively pricing in sharp downgrades outside AI and semiconductor-related names, which it called a clear overreaction.
The market had priced in steep EPS cuts on several occasions, most recently during the 2025 tariff shock, Citi said. In those cases, consensus EPS tended to decline gradually while market-implied EPS improved sharply, and share prices rebounded.
Citi acknowledged that Japanese equities could remain highly volatile in the near term but maintained its main scenario of a market pick-up toward year-end.