STOCK MARKETS

Aswath Damodaran values Anthropic at $76 a share, below its $83 IPO price

By Ananthu C U4 min readInvezz
Aswath Damodaran values Anthropic at $76 a share, below its $83 IPO price

Aswath Damodaran, the New York University finance professor widely known as the 'Dean of Valuation', estimates Anthropic's intrinsic value at approximately $76 per share, below the artificial intelligence company's $83 initial public offering (IPO) price.

In an updated valuation published ahead of the company's Nasdaq debut, Damodaran estimated Anthropic's aggregate equity value at approximately $1.35 trillion.

His calculations incorporated the company's latest financial results, higher computing costs and the possibility of tighter AI regulations.

Anthropic raised $81 billion in its IPO, making it the largest offering of all time.

The company priced its shares at $83 apiece, above its initial guidance range of $70 to $78.

The stock opened on Nasdaq at $111.50 under the ticker ANT giving it a $2 trillion valuation, before giving up some gains to trade at $96.33 at the time of writing.

Damodaran's assessment suggests that the stock's offering price was already above his estimated intrinsic value, while its subsequent market price represented a further premium.

Track Anthropic as valuation slips

Visit SiteDamodaran’s intrinsic value cut spotlights how costs and regulation pressure ANT’s price.51% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.

Damodaran lowers Anthropic valuation over rising costs and regulatory risks

Damodaran had initially valued Anthropic's equity at approximately $1.475 trillion in a November 2 analysis.

However, developments over the following 15 days prompted him to revise his assumptions.

The updated prospectus provided third-quarter financial information, while the US midterm election results raised questions about the future economics of the AI industry.

In particular, Damodaran expects data centres to become more expensive to build and AI regulations to become more stringent.

He reduced his assumption for sales generated per dollar of capital invested during the first five years from $3 to $2.75, reflecting higher expected infrastructure spending.

He also increased the anticipated regulatory drag on operating margins, adjusting his assumptions from 5% to 6%, with the target operating margin set at 26.5%.

Damodaran explained that these changes would increase the company's reinvestment requirements and reduce its expected cash flows.

"I do not want to overreact to the election results, but I do think it is prudent to assume that building data centers will become more expensive," he wrote.

Share count complicates Anthropic's intrinsic value calculation

A significant part of Damodaran's analysis focused on the difficulty of determining Anthropic's actual share count.

He argued that the presence of multiple share classes, restricted stock, and employee stock options makes it difficult to arrive at an accurate per-share valuation.

According to his analysis, Anthropic's share count could range from approximately 14.88 billion shares under the primary share method to 17.68 billion under the fully diluted approach.

The company has 1.026 billion restricted shares subject to a four-year vesting period and 1.774 billion outstanding options, of which 1.082 billion are already vested.

Damodaran argued that simply using either the primary or fully diluted share count could produce misleading results.

Instead, he favours an option-adjusted approach, which estimates the value of outstanding options and deducts that amount from aggregate equity value before dividing it by the primary and restricted shares.

"I would suggest viewing the option-adjusted value per share as the number closest to the truth," he wrote.

His calculations produced a range of values, with the primary share approach generating a higher estimate and the fully diluted method producing a lower one.

The option-adjusted valuation stood at approximately $76 per share, compared with the $83 IPO price.

Anthropic's growth prospects underpin long-term valuation

Despite the downward revision, Damodaran's valuation model assumes substantial growth for Anthropic over the coming years.

His assumptions project revenue growth of 190% in the next year, followed by 42% annual growth during years two to five.

Revenue growth subsequently moderates as the company matures.

The model also assumes that operating margins will improve as the company gains pricing power from premium AI products and computing costs grow more slowly than revenues.

Damodaran expects Anthropic's operating margin to reach 26.5% over time, while its cost of capital gradually declines as the company becomes more established.

His analysis also considers the substantial computing commitments the company has made, including lease, purchase, and infrastructure obligations.

He incorporated a 10% probability of failure into the valuation to account for the risks associated with those commitments.

Beyond the financial assumptions, Damodaran raised concerns about Anthropic's unusual voting structure.

He noted that a founder-owned share carries 50.01% of voting rights in perpetuity.

He compared the arrangement with government-held golden shares in privatised companies, arguing that concentrating such significant voting power in a single share could create risks.

Overall, Damodaran's analysis highlights the distinction between Anthropic's long-term growth potential and the price investors are willing to pay for its shares.

While his model anticipates substantial revenue expansion and improving profitability, higher infrastructure costs, regulatory uncertainty, and share dilution remain important considerations in assessing its valuation.