AI sell-off: These sectors held firm as tech slumped in Oct, Nov
Semiconductors, software, and memory stocks fell hard through October and early-November amid mounting questions over the long-term artificial intelligence trade.
But this sparked a rotation into defensive sectors, with healthcare, retail, logistics and REITs either holding their ground or even rising. The sectors also appeared attractive after vastly lagging tech during the AI-fueled surge over the past year.
Where the damage landed
| Stock | 1M return | 3M return |
|---|---|---|
| SanDisk (SNDK) | -44.7% | -46.1% |
| Marvell (MRVL) | -42.4% | -29.4% |
| ServiceNow (NOW) | -40.6% | -17.5% |
| Intel (INTC) | -39.2% | -41.8% |
| NVIDIA (NVDA) | -32.6% | -27.6% |
| Dell Tech (DELL) | -32.3% | -29.7% |
The pain spread beyond chips. Datadog (DDOG) fell 35.1% and Lumentum (LITE) fell 34.9% over the month. Copper miners Southern Copper (SCCO) (-28.8%) and Freeport-McMoRan (FCX) (-28.7%) also dropped. Both are likely hit by the same AI-infrastructure demand narrative, so Materials isn’t a clean hedge.
Where money hid
Healthcare looks like the strongest refuge:
- IDEXX Labs (IDXX): +23.6% over 1M, +27.8% over 3M
- Edwards Lifesciences (EW): +17.7% over 1M
- Regeneron (REGN): +14.3% over 1M
- Becton Dickinson (BDX): +9.7% over 1M, +42.2% YTD
Their earnings don’t depend on AI capex, so they gain when money leaves crowded growth trades.
Defensive consumer and restaurants:
- Chipotle (CMG): +22.4% over 1M
- McDonald’s (MCD): +10.5% over 1M
- Costco (COST): +10.1% over 1M, +27.6% YTD
- Target (TGT): +9.5% over 1M
- Lowe’s (LOW): +11.1% over 1M
Several of these had lagged earlier in the year, so part of the move looks like catch-up. The Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR (XLP) is up 6.1% over 3M and 22.4% over 1Y, with an RSI of 62.3. That is steady rather than explosive.
Industrials, insurance and real estate:
- UPS (UPS): +12.4% over 1M
- Aon (AON): +11.8% over 1M
- Simon Property (SPG): +8.8% over 1M
- Comcast (CMCSA): +11.2% over 1M
Tech that held
Not all tech fell. Two groups stood out:
- Motorola Solutions (MSI) rose 12.6% and Roper Technologies (ROP) rose 16.3%. Both sell steady, recurring-revenue products, not AI hardware.
- AppLovin (APP) gained 39.1% over 1M, but it’s still down 43.8% YTD. That is a rebound, not a safe haven.
Takeaways
- Insulation: Healthcare, consumer staples and defensive retail, logistics, insurance brokers and REITs all show relative strength.
- Risks: Defensive rallies can reverse quickly. Rotation reflects fear as much as fundamentals, and some leaders are rebounding from depressed levels (Target (TGT) is +77.3% YTD, for example). Cyclicals tied to AI capex, such as copper, offer no cover.